Mark Phillip Woodward

Email: mwoodward@cs.stanford.edu

Ph.D. Computer Science, Harvard University
   Advisor: Rob Wood
M.S. Computer Science, Stanford University
   Advisor: Andrew Ng
B.S. Computer Science, Stanford University
   Advisor: Jean-Claude Latombe

My research is focused on the creation of intelligent, interactive tools. Personally I hope that such tools will aid in the elimination of cancer, dementia, and natural death.



Publications

        Note: below is pre-deep learning research

  • Mark P. Woodward. Framing Human-Robot Task Communication as a Partially Observable Markov Decision Process. Ph.D. dissertation, Harvard University, 2012.
          The experimental results are mainly from the 2011 paper below. In addition to presenting that work in more detail, I derive the POMDP, I review the state-of-the-art in POMDP solvers, and I review related applications of POMDPs.
  • Mark P. Woodward and Robert J. Wood. Framing Human-Robot Task Communication as a POMDP. arXiv:1204.0280 [cs.RO], 2011.
  • Mark P. Woodward and Robert J. Wood. Learning from Humans as an I-POMDP. seeking venue.
          This is a position paper without supporting results. The paper argues that learning from humans should be modeled as a multiagent POMDP. An I-POMDP (Interactive POMDP), developed by Piotr Gmytrasiewicz and colleagues, is one of several approaches for extending the POMDP to the multiagent setting. The I-POMDP is argued for, but not derived, in this paper.
  • Mark P. Woodward and Robert J. Wood. Using Bayesian inference to learn high-level tasks from a human teacher. International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Pattern Recognition (AIPR), 2009.
          Here is a video of the robot using Bayesian inference to learn a task. In subsequent papers to this one, I argue for Bayesian inference along with rational action selection. This paper can be viewed as the first component of that: Bayesian inference. In this paper the robot chooses its next action using a local sampling technique; this action may be inefficient for the global objective of learning quickly. In subsequent papers the robot chooses its next action explicitly to maximize the global objective.

Projects

This is generally "pay-the-bills" work, or "get-rich-quick" ideas (which I am now trying to stay clear of).


Highlight Extraction in American Football - (Algorithm)

This is an example of a deep learning model for video segmentation and classification. This work was done for The Cube. Here it is applied to extracting highlights from high school football. Nothing about the model structure or code is specific to football. (video)



Identifying Runs, Passes, and Kicks in American Football - (Algorithm)

This is an example of a deep learning model for video segmentation and classification. This work was done for The Cube. Here it is applied to segmenting plays and labeling their type (run, pass, or kick) in high school football. Nothing about the model structure or code is specific to football. (video)



Possession Segmentation in Basketball - (Algorithm)

This is an example of a deep learning model for video segmentation. This work was done for The Cube. Here it is applied to segmenting possessions in high school basketball. Nothing about the model structure or code is specific to basketball. (video)



Play Segmentation in Football - (Algorithm)

This is early work on a deep learning model for detecting arbitrary events in video. The work was done for The Cube. Here it is applied to segmenting plays in videos of highschool football. (video)



Detection of Vocals in Songs - (Algorithm)

This is a demonstration of a deep learning model applied to the problem of detecting when vocals are present in a song. I needed a non-asr (automatic speech recognition) task to play with. I trained on the Jamendo song corpus. (video)



Inference in Toy Football - (Algorithm)

This is early work on a deep learning model for for detecting arbitrary events in video. The work was done for The Cube. Here it is applied to video of Toy Football. The plays are detected and are classified into 4 toy types (advance, incomplete, touchdown, and field goal). (video)



Tele-Operated Farm Equipment - (Hardware, Software)

This is an idea I explored of using cheap remote labor to automate farm equipment via teleoperation. See the video for a demonstration. The demo used a webcam on the crossbar, which is why I am leaning out of the way. I created hardware for actuating the steering wheel, and wrote software based on WebRTC to remotely view the scene and command the wheel. I used a cellphone for the internet connection (3G). The remote operator is controling the tractor from their home via a web interface. In the video the remote operator is able to keep the tractor in the middle of the row and make the turn at the end of the row. (video)


Autosteer for Tractors - (Hardware, Software)

This is a product I developed with a friend of mine who is a farmer. It is a 10 inch touch screen that plugs into John Deere tractors and automatically steers the tractor on a row. See the video for a walk through of the product. I designed and sourced fabrication of the cnc machined enclosure, designed and sourced the electronics, modified and configured linux for our needs, and wrote the Qt GUI. One of the larger accomplishments was listening on the CAN bus and reverse engineering the John Deere protocol for commanding the tractor. (video)



Object Tracking System - (Hardware, Algorithm)

This was a project to create a simple object tracking system. The system places an led circuit, blinking with a unique code, on each object to be tracked. This has an advantage over fiducial tracking systems, such as ARToolkit, in that the object need only take up a single pixel in the image; so roughly 10 times as many objects can be tracked. By running a Bayesian Filter on the video stream, the identity of a bright pixel can be inferred over time; e.g. "object 5", or "background noise". The image to the left shows the prototype breadboard with two blinking circuits on it, the switches set the code to be blinked. The movie below shows the tracking system in action. A computer displayed one blinking light and one background noise light, a webcam then recorded the screen, and the video was processed. Noise was added to both the background light and the coded light. The filter successfully tracked the identity of the objects ("Nob" for the background light, "Ob" for the coded light), and the phase of "Ob"'s code (since the filter doesn't know when the objected started blinking its code). The hypothesis with the maximum probability is drawn, as is the probability of that hypothesis. (video)


Object Detection, GentleBoost with Decision Stumps - (Algorithm)

This was a project for Leslie Valiant's Computational Learning Theory course. I was excited about recent developments in computer vision, namely the work on on object detection by Antonio Torralba et al. PAMI 2007, extended by Morgan Quigley et al. ICRA 2009, GentleBoosting decision stumps of image features. So I decided to implement their algorithm for one of my robots. See the report for details and results, but ignore the comparison to the perceptron with PCA dimension reduction, there are much better algorithms to compare against (I needed something simple to compare against). (report)


Cluster POMDP Solver - (Algorithm)

This was a project for Harvard's Massively Parallel Computing course. I was seeking a way to leverage computer clusters, specifically Amazon's EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud), for speeding up online exploration of POMDPs. A POMDP is a powerful framework for representing decision problems where an agent must make a series of decisions in a world whose state is only observable through noisy measurements; examples of this type of decision problem include: missile guidance, robot navigation, human-robot interaction, and high-frequency trading. Unfortunately, finding optimal, or near-optimal, actions for a POMDP is computationally intensive. My thesis surveys a number of approaches for addressing POMDP computation through algorithmic modifications. This project looked at how to throw more computational power at the problem. There are many parallel aspects of POMDP solvers which could be leveraged by a cluster. One of which is the agent's belief. I chose to distribute the agent's belief across the cluster (using MPI) and let each server solve the POMDP for its reduced belief. The solutions were then merged together to find the approximately optimal next action. The main benefit to this approach is that it requires a minimal amount of bandwidth, which is a main limitation of clusters. See the video for a summary of the project and results. See the presentation for the slides from the video. See the report for the details of the project. (video, presentation, report)


Generative Computer Vision - (Algorithm)

Current cutting edge object detection algorithms work by scanning across pixels in an image, extracting features around the current pixel, and passing these features to a classifier which determines if the object is at that pixel. If the object is being tracked in a video stream, the output of the classifier is then fed to a filtering algorithm to track the state of the system. This project explored an alternative approach, though extremely computationally intensive. The idea is that we can treat the raw image as measurements for the filtering algorithm. What is needed then is a measurement model which gives the probability of the measured image as a function of the state. The model used here was to generate the full world scene using the graphics card, and assume independent Gaussian noise on each pixel. This idea is mathematically elegant because it extends probabilistic filtering all the way down to the raw image measurements, but it is extremely computationally intensive; to update the filter you need to generate an image for all possible states of the world (often infinite). Thus, this is no where near real-time. Perhaps future processing power or algorithmic modifications will make this feasible. This idea is not new, early computer vision algorithms used a similar "model based" approach. Early approaches failed because of processing limitations and because of their deterministic nature (no probabilistic filtering). The image to the left shows the raw image next to the computer generated image corresponding to the maximum likelihood estimate for the scene. The bottom of the image shows the likelihood function for the position of the cone in world coordinates; the bright region in the lower left hand corner corresponds to the true location of the cone, and the black dot in the middle of this region is the maximum which was used to generate the right camera view.


Motor Controller - (Hardware)

With one of our larger robots, I was sick of wires connecting multiple circuit boards for each motor (usb interface, motor driver, joint encoder), so I designed this motor controller board. The board has an H-bridge that can drive 25 amps at up to 30 volts. There are inputs for wheel encoders or potentiometers. An Atmega324 handles the computation, and interfaces to a central computer via usb. The H-bridge components and microcontroller were chosen such that the motors can be driven above 20KHz, which is beyond the range of human hearing, so the motors will operate silently. The high voltage, high current H-bridge is electrically isolated from the microcontroller and usb circuitry.


Fire Alarm Repeater - (Hardware, Algorithm)

This is a device that listens for the sound of a smoke detector, if detected, it uses an embedded phone modem to connect to a remote server, which then sends me a text message. This was a fun project to experiment with embedded signal filters, and it saved me the monthly charges from a company like ADT. I implemented a band-pass digital filter (Butterworth) on an Atmega168 8-bit microcontroller to detect the roughly 3.3KHz beep generated by smoke detectors. The microcontroller continuously samples the microphone at 8KHz, updating the band-pass filter with each 10 bit sample. All circuitry was incorporated into a printed circuit board (PCB) and enclosed in a laser cut acrylic case. Since the microcontroller does not have a floating point unit, a simple fixed-point math library was written.


Humanoid Servo Robot - (Hardware)

This is a robot I constructed from standard hobby servos. The servo mechanical connections were 3-d printed and the torso and base plates were laser cut from acrylic. There are seven degrees of freedom in the humanoid torso. The wheeled base uses two hobby servos modified for continuous rotation as in the Simple Servo Robot below. The robot is equipped with a wireless web camera which streams images to a laptop. The laptop controls the robot via the RC Transmitter Interface described below.



Simple Servo Robot - (Hardware)

I a needed quick robot to demonstrate an algorithm in a paper. This robot took one day to create. It consists of two standard hobby servos, modified for continuous rotation, hot glued to two rc car wheels and mounted to a piece of acrylic. A third hobby servo raises and lowers a laser-cut acrylic ring. The servos are connected to a standard hobby receiver and the robot is controlled from the laptop via the RC Transmitter Interface described below. The robot is tracked with a standard web camera detecting the colored construction paper. See the video below from the AIPR 2008 paper, for the robot in action. (video - image - image)


Kalman Filter for an Indoor Helicopter - (Algorithm)

In support of an indoor helicopter project at the Harvard Microrobotics Laboratory, I implemented a Kalman filter. The state space consisted of 16 elements: 7 for the position and orientation of the helicopter (orientation was represented with a quaternion), 6 for the linear and angular velocities, and 6 for the linear and angular accelerations. The motion model assumed constant acceleration (this is the same assumption made in the Kalman filter used by Stanford's autonomous helicopter). Measurement models were created for the onboard IMU and vision based position estimate. The video below shows a simulated helicopter with noisy measurements filtered to a trajectory consistent with the helicopter's dynamics. The true helicopter state and the estimated state are shown. The estimated state is drawn offset from the true state for visualization. Note that the filter only sees the true helicopter through the noisy measurements. The vision based position estimate has a standard deviation of 20cm, but by integrating over time, making use of the IMU measurements, and the helicopter dynamics, the estimated RMS position error is on the order of 2-4cm. (video)


Autonomous Indoor Vehicle - (Hardware, Algorithm)

This is one of the platforms which I created to support my research at Harvard. The vehicle has two drive wheels and a rear skid plate. The robot is equipped with a 2GHz processor, a laser scanner, a firewire camera, an inertial measurement unit (IMU), wheel encoders, and two hours of battery life. The frame was laser cut from acrylic. Custom printed circuit boards (PCBs) were designed to interface the IMU and wheel encoders with the computer. Here is an early version of the robot. In the video below, the robot maps and localizes a cluttered room using the FastSLAM algorithm (the robot starts to move about 20 seconds into the video) (I had not yet fit the parameters of the motion model and measurement models when this video was taken, but the hand coded parameters performed reasonably well). (video, image, image)


Robot Software Infrastructure - (Algorithm)

This is an infrastructure for communicating between the various software components within a robot; it consisting of a software library and a central messaging server. The architecture was inspired by Mike Montemerlo's architecture for Stanford's DARPA Grand Challenge entry, Stanley. Each driver, gui, and application, is coded as a stand alone application. Each application can subscribe to messages and publish its own messages. A library provides the publish, subscribe, and event generation functions. Internally, the library sends messages over TCP/IP via a simple message server application. This is a very light system (less than 1000 lines of code) which provides a strict interface between software components. This architecture is similar to Willow Garage's robot operating system (ROS); Morgan Quigley, the original architect of ROS, and I were both inspired by the Stanley architecture. Morgan created what would become ROS and I created this Infrastructure. I continue to use this for personal use, since it is light weight and my drivers are already written for it, but I recommend that others use ROS as it is more robust and has a broad and active support base.


Fast SLAM on a Microcontroller - (Algorithm)

Neato Robotics was developing a robotic vacuum that would build a map of a home and localize itself within the map. This problem is often called simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM). I advised them on the FastSLAM algorithm and, along with Vlad Ermakov at Neato Robotics, modified the FastSLAM algorithm to run on an Atmel microcontroller. The vacuum has since been released to positives reviews.


Camera Based Localization - (Algorithm)

For Sebastian Thrun's Statistical Robotics course, I developed a localization system that turns a 2d video stream into a range scanner. Monte-carlo localization was then used to localize the robot within a map, given this range data. See the report and presentation for details. See the video for a demonstration of the system; the robot follows an L-bend in a hallway, and turns around mid way down the next segment. (report, presentation, video)



Speech Recognizer for Robot Dog - (Algorithm)

For Dan Jorafsky's Speech Recognition course, I developed from scratch a complete speech recognizer for commanding a robot dog, including software for training the HMM. The acoustic model uses three subphones per phoneme. A single gaussian is fit for each subphone. Viterbi decoding is used for recognition and during training. The image to the left shows the flow for training the system. See the report for details. (report)


Tracking a Ground Vehicle from a Helicopter - (Algorithm)

This was a project under Professor Andrew Ng. I developed vision software to track a ground vehicle in a helicopter mounted video stream. The video below shows the helicopter autonomously tracking a remote controlled car using this vision software. (video)



Carrier Phase Differential GPS - (Hardware)

Aerobatic control of the Stanford autonomous helicopter required accurate position estimates. Standard GPS suffers inaccuracies due to atmospheric conditions which affect the time of flight of the satellite signals. Differential GPS (DGPS) corrects for these atmospheric conditions using a reference signal from a base station whose position is know. Carrier phase DGPS (CP-DGPS) employs a base station as well, but compares the phase of the raw carrier sine wave rather than the coded signal on top of the sine wave. This results in 3d position accuracies of a few centimeters, which is what is needed for aerobatic helicopter control. In this project, Michael Vitas and I implemented CP-DGPS using Novatel's superstar II GPS boards. See Michael's report below for an introduction to CP-DGPS and for results from our experiments. To support this project I created a printed circuit board (PCB) for communicating with the superstar II. (report)


RC Transmitter Interface - (Hardware)

Because of their low cost and robustness, I have often used standard hobby remote control (RC) equipment in my robots. On the back of many RC transmitters is a trainer port, which allows the signals from one transmitter to be output through another transmitter. This is a PCB that I designed which allow a computer to send signals through a transmitter's trainer port.



Air Hockey Playing Robot - (Algorithm)

For Oussama Khatib's Experimental Robotics course, John Rogers, Archan Padmanabhan, and I created an air hockey playing robot. We used a Puma 500 robot arm with a paddle as the end effector, and tracked the hockey puck using a standard webcam. The arm was force controlled using cubic spline trajectories in operational space. See the report for a brief description. The video shows the robot in action. (report - video)



Space-Indexed Dynamic Program - (Algorithm)

I implemented and evaluated the space-indexed dynamic programming (SIDP) control algorithm on Stanley, Stanford's autonomous off-road vehicle. These results were used in the paper that introduced SIDP (paper).



Tracking multiple objects using optical flow and particle filters - (Algorithm)

For Sebastian Thrun's Introduction to Computer Vision course, I developed a vision system that tracks multiple vehicles in a video stream. The algorithm uses optical flow, so no model of the cars' appearance is needed. The filtering over time is done with a particle filter (in retrospect this was a gross approximation to the particle filter, but it worked). See the report for details and the video for a demonstration. (report - video)


OBD-II Car Interface - (Hardware)

Since the mid 1980s, most automobiles have been equipped with a diagnostic port under the driver side dashboard. The main protocol spoken by this port is called OBD-II. At the time, the diagnostic tools for connecting to this port were expensive, so I created a board that would allow me to access and clear my car's diagnostic codes via my laptop's USB port. This was the first printed circuit board (PCB) that I designed; it is missing many standard features, such as a ground plane and decoupling capacitors, but it works well.


Autonomous RC Car - (Hardware)

This is localization and control hardware that I created to support my undergraduate senior project. Localization: The laser, mounted between the rear shocks, has a vertical line lens and spins at a known angular velocity. Three boxes with light dependent resistors (LDR), pictured in the lower right, are placed in a known location in the environment. Given the known position of the boxes, the known angular rate of the laser, and the measured laser arrival delay between the boxes, the position of the vehicle can be computed. Control: A small box was mounted to the back of the transmitter. You can see it propping up the transmitter. The box contains two digital to analog converters (DACs) that speak I2C. The DAC outputs were connected to the trigger and wheel potentiometer outputs in the transmitter. The DAC I2C input was "bit banged" from a computer's serial port. See the report for details. (report)


Teaching

    Guest Lectures

  • CS181 - Intelligent Machines: Perception, Learning, and Uncertainty, Harvard
       lecture topics: Kalman filtering
  • CS189r - Autonomous Multi-Robot Systems, Harvard
       lecture topics: Kalman filtering, PID control
  • ES259 - Advanced Introduction to Robotics, Harvard
       lecture topics: Bayesian inference, Kalman filtering, particle filtering

    T.A.

  • CS106A - Programming Methodology, Stanford (Winter 2001)
  • CS148 - Introduction to Computer Graphics, Stanford (Fall 2004)
  • CS528 - Broad Area Colloquium for Artificial Intelligence, Geometry, Graphics and Computer Vision, Stanford (Fall 2005, Winter 2006)
  • CS225A - Experimental Robotics, Stanford (Winter 2006)
  • ES125* - Mechanical Systems, Harvard (Fall 2007)
  • * received highest possible rating from students

Employment

  • Deep Intent (2017-present) - DeepIntent provides services for online advertisers. I apply deep learning to automating brand safety for video advertisements.
  • The Cube (2016-2017) - The Cube is a startup which provides services for streaming high school events. I focused on applying deep learning techniques to automating the extractraction of highlights from their videos.
  • Full Spectrum Laser (2015) - Full Spectrum Laser makes laser cutters and SLA/DLP 3D printers. I was their Chief Technology Officer.
  • Neato Robotics (2006, 2012-2014) - Neato Robotics was developing a robotic vacuum. I advised them on a mapping and localization algorithm that could run on a cheap microcontroller. See the "Fast SLAM on a Microcontroller" project above for more details. Later I helped them extend the algorithms
  • Lockheed Martin, Advanced Technology Center (2001-2004) - The ATC (Advanced Technology Center) is a research division of Lockheed Martin. At the ATC I worked on distributed localization and time synchronization algorithms for the DARPA NEST Program. The algorithms were implemented on an Atmel micro-controller (Berkeley Motes). I also created a distributed software layer which enabled solar scientists to share their mission data with other scientists and to search the data of other scientists.

©2017 Mark Phillip Woodward